I'm not sure if it's the play itself, or just this latest adaptation by David Auburn, but Langdon Mitchell's premise of a divorced woman, newly engaged to a divorced man was better told by the prolific Phillip Barry in The Philadelphia Story, which premiered on Broadway some six years after The New York Idea's last revival. One can't help but wonder if Mr. Barry had seen that production.
Set in 1906, Mr. Mitchell's work plods through the unseemliness of divorce at the time, punctuated by the dithering and frowns of the mother and aunt of the groom. The result is an evening of theatrical fluff, verging on lint.
The cast is up for the game and make noble if unsuccessful efforts to breathe life into the stodgy plot. As Cynthia Karslake (the divorced bride-to-be), Jaime Ray Newman is perky, but trapped. Jeremy Shamos's John Karslake, her ex, comes across as mostly embarrassed to be caught up in the proceedings, and not from just his character's perspective.
